Tax Audit Penalties: What Happens if You Get Audited and Fail

Updated on February 21, 2024

At a Glance

  • A tax audit is a detailed examination of your tax return by tax authorities to ensure the accuracy of income and deductions reported.
  • Failing an audit may result in civil penalties, criminal charges, damaged credit, and more. Severity depends on the degree of non-compliance.
  • You have the right to appeal the results of the audit if you believe the tax authorities were incorrect.
  • After an audit, you can file an amended tax return to correct any errors or omissions that were discovered.

Surprises are almost always pleasant to have around. However, there is one surprise that nobody wants: a tax audit. They bring a lot of stress, and may even lead to financial losses if there are discrepancies in your tax filing. In this article, we will dive into the process of tax audits and explore what happens if you get audited and fail. This way, you will know how to prepare yourself for it.

What Is an Audit?

In simple words, an audit is like someone giving your tax return a thorough examination. This often happens if someone finds something unusual in your tax filing, but other actions may trigger this as well. It’s an in-depth review of your financial records to determine if you’ve accurately reported your income and deductions.

During an audit, the tax authorities will go through your records in detail, asking for supporting documents, scrutinizing your expenses, and even asking uncomfortable questions. It may sound scary, but there is no need to panic, and it doesn’t mean you’re automatically guilty. It’s just a way for the tax man to ensure everyone is playing by the rules.

Stages of an Audit

When you receive that audit notice, it’s natural to feel a mix of anxiety, frustration, and confusion. But understanding the process can help alleviate some of those negative emotions. So, let’s break it down.

The Audit Notice Stage

First and foremost, audits can be triggered by various factors. Sometimes, it’s simply a random selection, where your name is taken out of a list for no particular reason. Other times, it’s because your tax return raised some red flags. Maybe you claimed an unusually high amount of deductions, or your income doesn’t match the information the tax authorities have on file. Regardless of the reason, an audit is an opportunity for the tax authorities to dig deeper into your financial affairs.

The Audit Preparation Stage

Once you receive the audit notice, you’ll typically be given a timeframe to gather all the necessary documents and prepare for the upcoming examination. This is where the real work begins. You’ll need to gather your receipts, bank statements, invoices, and any other relevant records that support the information on your tax return.

The Audit Review Stage

During the actual audit, you may be summoned to meet with a tax auditor in person, or it could be conducted through correspondence, where you’ll send all your documents and explanations via mail or email. Either way, you should be prepared for a thorough review. The auditor will meticulously analyze your income, deductions, credits, and any other items that may impact your tax liability.

What to Expect During an Audit

There are three main types of audits you may be asked to partake in: correspondence audits, office audits, and field audits. Correspondence audits are typically the least invasive, where the tax authorities will request additional information or clarification on specific items through mail or email. Office audits, on the other hand, require you to visit a local tax office and bring all your records for examination. Field audits are the most comprehensive and intimidating. A tax auditor will come to your place of business or home to conduct the audit on-site.

During the audit, the tax authorities may ask you a series of questions to gain a better understanding of your financial situation. These questions can range from simple inquiries about certain expenses to more complex queries about your business operations. It’s important to answer truthfully and provide any necessary documentation to support your answers. Remember, honesty is key!

Once the audit is complete, you’ll receive a notification of the findings. If everything checks out and your tax return is deemed accurate, it means you passed the audit. However, if discrepancies are found, you may be required to pay additional taxes, penalties, or interest. In some cases, the audit may even lead to a criminal investigation if fraud or intentional misreporting is suspected.

While they may not be the most enjoyable experience, audits serve an important purpose in maintaining the integrity of the tax system. So, the next time you receive that dreaded audit notice, take a deep breath, gather your records, and face it head-on. After all, knowledge is power!

What Happens If You Get Audited and Fail?

Sometimes, an audit may lead to failure, a thought that can disrupt the tranquility of every citizen. But keep in mind that failing an audit doesn’t mean you’re heading straight to tax jail. However, you can expect a series of consequences. This will depend mostly on what your auditors found on you, and how severe your case may be.

The first thing you can expect is some good old-fashioned penalties. These penalties can vary depending on the severity of your non-compliance and whether you made the mistake out of carelessness or with malicious intent. The tax authorities are very serious when it comes to enforcing the law, and will likely tap into the list of punishments appropriate for your case.

Civil Charges

One of the most common penalties you might face is the civil penalty, which is one of the least severe forms. It’s a financial penalty that the tax authorities can impose as a form of punishment for failing to comply with the tax laws. At the end of it, you might end up paying even more than you originally owed.

Criminal Charges

If your non-compliance goes beyond mere negligence and the tax man suspects more sinister motives, you could find yourself facing criminal charges. Tax evasion is no joke, and committing this offense can lead to fines, probation, or even some quality time behind bars. Orange might be the new black, but it certainly doesn’t look good on anyone.

Other Consequences

Failing an audit can have additional consequences that might make you want to crawl into a hole and never come out. You could end up with a tarnished reputation, damaged credit, and even be denied certain business opportunities.

Moreover, the tax authorities might decide to not only audit your current tax return but also investigate your previous returns. So, all those questionable deductions and creative accounting methods you used in the past might come back to haunt you.

Can You Appeal the Results of an Audit?

Now that we’ve explored the consequences of failing an audit, you might be wondering if there’s a way to get yourself out of this situation. You’ll be happy to know there is, based on specific circumstances. You do have the right to appeal the results of an audit if you believe the tax authorities got it wrong. This should be your option if you know for a fact you were truthful, and the tax discrepancies were not your fault in the slightest.

Keep in mind that appealing the results of an audit can bring a series of additional steps in itself. It requires gathering extra evidence, presenting your case to the tax authorities, and possibly even going to tax court. However, if you do believe you were wronged, this may be the best way to get the justice that you deserve.

How Do You File an Amended Tax Return?

You’ve survived the audit, appealed the results, and now you’re left wondering how to correct the mistakes you made on your tax return. You’ll be pleased to know that there are still some steps you can take. You can file an amended tax return to fix any errors or omissions that you’ve discovered along the way.

  1. Gather your supporting documents: Find all the relevant receipts and any other relevant documents that will help you correct your tax return.
  2. Use Form 1040X: This is the form that will allow you to amend your tax return. Just make sure to fill it out accurately and provide all the necessary information.
  3. Mail it in: Once you’ve completed the form, and double-checked for any additional errors, it’s time to put it in an envelope and send it on its way. Make sure to check the IRS website for the correct mailing address based on your location.

With a little bit of patience and some perseverance, you can correct your tax return and hopefully avoid any future visits from the tax authorities. Bear in mind that at this point, you may still be on the blacklist of the IRS. You may want to be careful how you file your taxes from this point on, as they will probably watch your every move. A financial advisor can help you at this point.

The Bottom Line

Remember, the world of taxes may seem scary at times, but with the right knowledge, a touch of hope, and a good dose of common sense, you’ll be able to navigate through your tax audits and come out on the other side unscathed. Stay informed, stay compliant, and keep the number of audits you get at a minimum.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is a tax audit?

A tax audit is a detailed examination of your tax return by tax authorities to ensure the accuracy of income and deductions reported.

What triggers a tax audit?

Several factors can trigger a tax audit, such as an unusually high amount of deductions, mismatched income information, or sometimes it’s simply a random selection.

What happens during a tax audit?

During a tax audit, tax authorities will review your financial records in detail, ask for supporting documents, scrutinize your expenses, and ask relevant questions to ensure the accuracy of your tax return.

What are the different types of tax audits?

There are three main types of tax audits: correspondence audits, office audits, and field audits. The type of audit you undergo depends on the complexity of the issues raised by your tax return.

What happens if I fail a tax audit?

If you fail a tax audit, you may face penalties such as paying additional taxes, interest, or fines. In severe cases, you could face criminal charges or damage to your credit and reputation.

Can I appeal the results of a tax audit?

Yes, if you believe the tax authorities have made an error during the audit, you have the right to appeal the results.

How do I appeal the results of a tax audit?

To appeal a tax audit, you need to gather additional evidence, present your case to the tax authorities, and possibly even go to tax court.

How can I amend my tax return?

To amend your tax return, you need to gather your supporting documents, use Form 1040X to correct any errors or omissions, and mail the completed form to the IRS.

What are the consequences of failing a tax audit?

Consequences of failing a tax audit can range from paying civil penalties to facing criminal charges. In addition, you could end up with a tarnished reputation, damaged credit, and loss of certain business opportunities.

What should I do to avoid a tax audit?

To avoid a tax audit, ensure that your tax return is accurate and truthful. Keep good records of your income and deductions and consult a tax professional if you’re unsure about anything related to your tax return.

I agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )
Join over 100,000 visitors who are receiving our newsletter and learn more about finance, immigration, and more!
We hate spam. Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.

Get the Checklist